Clash of Cultures

 

RAW MILK VERSUS PASTURIZED: A CLASH OF CULTURES

In 2016, the International Association for Food Protection (IAFP) allowed a debate on the merits of raw milk versus pasteurized at its annual conference.

The most interesting aspect of the debate was the clear difference in world view between the for and against camps. “My assumption is not that nature is perfect,” said Jeff Kornacki, PhD a proponent of pasteurization. “My assumption is that nature is wild and can be dangerous.” He then referenced the death angel mushroom, which can kill you with one bite—as if to say that raw milk is not just risky, but downright toxic.

True to his public health training, Kornacki noted that 25 percent of foodborne illnesses were associated with milk in 1938; now it’s less than one percent. He left out the fact that these illnesses were in steep decline long before pasteurization became mandatory. Better housing, the advent of refrigeration, the replacement of the horse with the car, better water management, and the closing of filthy inner-city dairies are more likely candidates for the decline.

But to compare the food that nourishes all mammalian infants to a death angel mushroom shows the blinkers that hamper rational thought among public health officials.

When you assume that nature is imperfect and dangerous, you end up with all kinds of inappropriate procedures—from pasteurization to routine antibiotics to vaccinations. For sure, nature needs a certain amount of thoughtful management to make it compatible with human life, but during the last few decades, science has revealed the fact that raw milk is indeed a perfect food—full of many marvels, with more likely to be revealed. Raw milk contains numerous bioactive components that kill pathogens, strengthen the immune system, create a strong gut wall, nourish our gut bacteria, ensure the assimilation of 100 percent of all the nutrients in the milk, and protect it against rot. These are largely destroyed by the rust belt technology of pasteurization.

The closer we look at nature—whether we study raw milk, the human biome, the construction of bone, the radar system of bats or the length of eyelashes in different species, the more we are guided to the obvious conclusion: nature is infused with wisdom, and it is incumbent on man to recognize and honor that wisdom. The raw milk drinker looks at nature with awe and respect; the raw milk opponent looks at nature with fear and anger, as something that needs to be sanitized and “improved.”

November 24, 2014

Is This the Beginning of a Goat Milk Craze?

Goat milk soft-serve ice cream, dulce de leche, and gin fizz cocktails all made from goat’s milk are popping up in high-end grocery stores and on […]
October 31, 2014

Raw Milk Taste Test: Does Raw Milk Really Taste Better Than Pasteurized Milk?

Many raw milk drinkers rave about the quality of it, praising its creamy texture and fresh taste. One curious Indiana man decided he would see what […]
October 25, 2014

A Recluse Milkman Makes the Rounds

Every Tuesday in the tiny town of Recluse, Wyoming, a milkman makes his rounds. He might not dress the part of the classic American milkman from […]
September 12, 2014

New Use for Raw Milk: Artisanal Soaps

People with sensitive skin might be excited to learn that a new take on the farm-to-table trend means gentler soaps for them. In West Virginia, where […]
September 8, 2014

Raw Milk Open Barn Party Held in Vermont

In celebration of the recent change in law that now allows raw milk drinkers to pick up their milk at farmers markets, Rural Vermont and the […]
August 1, 2014

Reporting Double Standard for Pasteurized Milk

By David Gumpert From thecompletepatient.com, June 1, 2014. Reprinted with permission. In official reports, you’d never know it was pasteurized dairy making people sick. It seems […]
July 21, 2014

Is Mainstream Media Reaching a Tipping Point in the Dietary Debate?

Thirty years after TIME Magazine cover “Cholesterol…And Now the Bad News,” the magazine’s June 23, 2014 issue featured a cover titled “Eat Butter: Scientists labeled fat […]
July 7, 2014

Federal Ruling Gives Qualified Nutrition Professionals Access to Hospitals

Patients are now afforded a bit more flexibility in determining the type of nutrition provider they want overseeing their care thanks to a recent federal ruling […]
May 26, 2014

Mark Bittman Proclaims “Butter is Back” in The New York Times

Mark Bittman, an award-winning food columnist for The New York Times, is happy to report that the tides are finally turning away from low-fat diets back […]
Raw Milk Finder